The Story of a Life
By AHARON APPELFELD
At what point does my memory begin? It sometimes seems to me as if it began
only when I was four, when we set off for the first time, Mother, Father, and
I, for a vacation into the heart of the shadowy, moist forests of the
Carpathians. But I sometimes think that memory began to bud from within me
before that, in my room, next to the double-glazed window that was decorated
with paper flowers. Snow is falling, and fleecy soft flakes are slowly coming
down from the sky with a sound so faint that you cannot hear it. For hours I
sit and gaze in wonder, until I merge with the white flow and drift off to
A clearer memory is linked for me to one word, too long and rather hard to
pronounce, Erdbeeren, which means “strawberries” in German. It is spring.
Mother is standing at the open window. I am perched on a chair next to her, and
suddenly, from a side alley, there appears a young Ruthenian girl. She is
carrying a broad, circular wicker basket full of strawberries on her head.
“Erdbeeren!” Mother calls out. Her call is not directed at the girl but at
Father, who is in the back garden and very near the girl. Father stops her, she
lifts the basket off her head, and they speak for a moment. Father laughs,
draws out a banknote from the pocket of his jacket, and presents it to the
girl, who, in exchange, gives him the basket with all the strawberries inside
it. Father comes up the steps and enters the house. Now one can see it close
up: the basket is not deep but extremely wide; the berries are tiny and red and
still alive with the scent of the forest. I so want to put out my hand and take
a handful from the basket, but I know that this is completely forbidden, and I
restrain myself. Still, my mother understands me, and she takes a handful from
the basket, rinses them, and serves me them in a small bowl. I’m so happy that
I can hardly breathe.
Here the ritual begins: Mother sprinkles powdered sugar on the tiny fruit, adds
cream, and serves up the delicacy to each of us. There’s no need to ask for
another portion: Mother ladles it out, more and more, and we feast on it with
great relish, as if we are about to finish the strawberries. But there is
nothing to worry about, the basket is still full, and even if we go on eating all
through the night, it won’t get any emptier. “A pity there are no guests,” says
Mother. Father laughs quietly, as if a partner to a conspiracy. And the
following day, too, we eat more overflowing portions, though distractedly and
no longer with a ravenous appetite. Mother puts the remaining strawberries in
the pantry. Later I saw, with my very own eyes, how the glorious berries had
turned grayish and had shriveled up; for the rest of the day, I felt sad
whenever I remembered them. But the woven basket, made of simple twigs,
remained in our home for many days, and every time I glanced at it, I would
remember how it had looked like a red crown when it rested on the head of the
Ruthenian peasant girl.
. . .
memories are the walks along the banks of the river, on the paths by the
fields, and on the grassy meadows. I see us climb a hill, sit on top of it, and
gaze around. Speaking little, my parents listen attentively. With Mother it is
more obvious. When she listens, her large eyes are wide open, as if trying to
take in everything around her. At home, too, there is more quiet than talking.
Nothing spoken—no phrases—remain in my memory from those distant days, only
Mother’s gaze. It was filled with so much softness and tender solicitude that I
feel it to this very day.
Our house is spacious and has many rooms. One balcony faces the street, and the
other one, the public park. The drapes are long, trailing on the parquet floor.
When the maid changes them, a scent of starch fills the whole house. But even more
than the drapes, I love the floor—or, rather, the carpet that covers the floor.
On its floral patterns I construct streets and houses from wooden blocks and
populate them with stuffed bears and tin dogs. The carpet is thick and soft,
and I sink into it for hours, pretending that I’m traveling on a train,
crossing continents, and eventually arriving at my grandfather’s village.
In summer we will travel to Grandfather’s village, and just thinking of it
induces a sort of drowsiness, as memories of the previous visit surface. But
the images I see in my memory have become so hazy since then that they are more
like a dream. All the same, one word remains, and that is
mestameh—“presumably.” The word is strange and incomprehensible, yet
Grandmother repeats it several times a day. Many times I was about to ask what
this strange word meant, but I didn’t. Mother and I speak German. Sometimes it
seems to me that the way Grandfather and Grandmother talk makes Mother
uncomfortable, and that she’d prefer for me not to hear their language. All the
same, I summon up the courage and ask, “What’s the language that Grandfather
and Grandmother are speaking?”
“Yiddish,” Mother whispers in my ear.
Days in the village are long, stretching deep into the white night. In the village
there are no carpets, only mats. Even the guest room has a mat. At the touch of
a foot, the mat makes a dry rustling sound. Mother sits next to me and carves
into a watermelon. In the village there are no restaurants and no cinema; we
sit out in the yard till late, watching the sunset that goes on till the middle
of the night. I try hard not to doze off, but eventually I fall asleep.
Here the days are full of small enchantments. A band of three Gypsies suddenly
enters the yard and bursts into the sad strains of violin music. Grandmother
doesn’t lose her temper; she knows them well and lets them go on. Their playing
makes me sadder and sadder, and I want to cry. Mother helps out and asks the
Gypsies to stop playing, but they won’t. “Don’t stop us! This is the way we
“But it’s frightening for the child,” Mother implores.
“There’s nothing to fear—we’re not devils.”
Eventually Mother gives them a banknote, and they stop playing. One of the
Gypsies tries to come up and be nice to me, but Mother keeps him at a distance.
Just as the Gypsies have left the back yard, a chimney sweep appears. A tall
man, with black cables wound completely around his torso, he sets to work
without delay. His face is all sooty, and when he stands by the chimney flue he
looks like one of those demons from the tales of the Brothers Grimm that Mother
reads me before I go to sleep. I want to let Mother in on this secret, but I
Toward evening, the cows come back from the pasture. The lowing and mooing and
the dust fill the air with melancholy, but this is soon dispelled by the
nightly ritual of boiling up preserves. Plum jam, pear-and-plum jam,
ripe-cherry jam—each jam has its appointed hour of the night. Grandmother takes
a large copper pot from the kitchen and puts it on the garden bonfire, which
has been kindled since twilight. Now the copper pot is gleaming golden. The
boiling goes on for most of the night. Grandmother tastes and stirs, adds
laurel leaves, and eventually serves me a dish of warm jam. The sweetness, for
which I have waited so eagerly, brings me no happiness this time. The fear that
the night will end and that in the morning we will have to climb into a
carriage to return to the city—this fear now grips me, stealthily spoiling my
happiness. I take Mother’s hand and kiss it, kiss it again and again, until,
intoxicated with all the night scents, I fall asleep on the rush mat.
In the country, I’m with Mother. Father remains in the city to run the
business, and when he suddenly appears, he seems alien to me. With Mother I go
out to the meadows by the river, or, rather, by one of the streams of the River
Prut. The waters flow slowly, the clearness is dazzling, and one’s feet sink
into the soft ground.
In the summer, days stretch out slowly and without end. I know how to count up
to forty, to draw flowers, and in another day or two I’ll know how to write my
name in block letters. Mother doesn’t leave me for a moment. Her closeness is
so wonderful that even a moment without her makes me sad. Sometimes,
unexpectedly, I ask her about God, or about when I was born. Mother is
embarrassed by these questions, and it seems to me that she blushes. On one
occasion she tells me, “God is in the sky, and He knows everything.” The answer
delights me as much as if I had been presented with an enchanted gift. But for
the most part her answers are short, as if she simply has to discharge a duty.
Sometimes I keep on asking, but it doesn’t make her talk more.
Unlike Mother, Grandmother is a large and sturdy woman, and when she places her
two hands on the broad wooden table, they fill it. As she talks, she describes
things, and you can tell that she loves what she’s describing: the vegetables
in the garden, for example, or the orchard behind the cowshed. It’s hard to understand
how Grandmother can be my mother’s mother. Next to her, Mother looks like a
pale shadow. Grandmother frequently scolds her daughter for leaving some of her
soup in the bowl, or a piece of vegetable pie on her plate. Grandmother has
firm views on everything: how to grow vegetables, when to pick plums, who is an
honest man and who is not. When it comes to children, her convictions are even
firmer: children should go to bed before dark, and not at 9 p.m. Mother, on the
other hand, doesn’t see any harm in a child falling asleep on the straw
Grandmother isn’t always in a decisive mood. Sometimes she closes her eyes
tight, seems to sink into her large body, and tells Mother about bygone days. I
understand nothing of what she says, and yet I enjoy listening to her. When she
picks me up and lifts me high above her head, I feel as weak as if I were still
a baby. Grandfather is tall and thin and seldom speaks. He leaves for prayers
early in the morning, and when he returns, the table is laden with vegetables, cheeses, and fried eggs.
Grandfather’s presence imparts silence to us all. He does not look at us and we
do not look at him, but on the Sabbath eve his face softens. Grandmother irons
a white shirt for him, and we set out for the synagogue.
The walk to the synagogue is long and full of wonders. A horse stands in
astonishment, and there is a small girl next to it, about my height. She also
stands and stares. Not far from them, a foal is rolling on the grass. The
strong, barrel-like creature is stretched on its back, waving its legs in the
air as if it has been toppled and is thrashing about, as I sometimes do. Then,
just to show everyone that it wasn’t knocked down, it gets back up. There is
astonishment in the dozens of pairs of eyes of the horses, sheep, and goats who
are all following the foal’s movements, happy that it’s back on its feet.
Grandfather walks in silence, but his silence is not frightening. We move along
fast but stop every few minutes. And for a moment it seems to me that he wants
to show me something and to name it, the way Father does. I am wrong.
Grandfather continues in silence, and what escapes from his mouth is swallowed
up and not comprehensible, but then he lets some words escape that I can
understand. “God,” he says, “is in the sky and there is nothing to fear.” The
gestures that go with the words are even clearer than the words themselves.
Grandfather’s synagogue is small and made of wood. By the light of day it
resembles a roadside chapel, but it’s longer and has no statues or objects on
the shelves. The entrance is low, and Grandfather has to stoop to enter. I
follow. Here a surprise awaits us: many golden candles are stuck into two
troughs of sand and radiate a diffused light along with the scent of beeswax.
The prayers are almost silent. Grandfather prays with his eyes closed, and the
candlelight flickers on his forehead. All those praying are absorbed in their
prayer. Not me. For some reason I have suddenly remembered the city, the damp
streets after the rain. In the summer, sudden showers fall, and Father drags me
after him, down narrow alleys, from one square to another. Father doesn’t go to
synagogue; he is passionate about natural beauty, and he also loves unusual
buildings, churches, chapels, and cafés where they serve coffee in fine cups.
Grandfather breaks into my imaginings. He bends down and shows me the prayer
book, the yellow pages with the large black letters leaping out from within it.
All the movements here are careful and secretive. I don’t understand anything.
For a moment it seems to me that the lions that are above the Holy Ark are
about to stir and leap down. The prayers are conducted in whispers. Sometimes a
louder voice rises on the swell, dragging the whisperers after it. This is the
home of God, and people come here in order to sense His presence. Only I don’t
know how to talk to Him. If I knew how to read the prayer book, I would also be
able to see the wonders and the secrets, but for right now I have to hide
myself away so that God won’t see my ignorance.
The man leading the prayers reads and embellishes and reads—and as he does, he
skips over some passages, bowing to the right and to the left. He’s nearest to
the Holy Ark and tries to influence God; all the others also raise their heads,
subjugating their will to the will of God.
While this is going on, the candles stuck in the sand troughs burn out, and
then the men take off their prayer shawls and a kind of quiet wonderment shines
in their eyes, as if they understand something they didn’t understand before.
Leaving the synagogue takes a long time. The elderly leave first, and only then
do all the others file out. I already want to be outside, where the air is
clear and people talk to one another, not to God.
Once again, we’re on our way. Grandfather hums a prayer, but it’s a different
kind of prayer, not strained, and with a more casual melody. The sky is full of
stars; their light spills onto our heads. Grandfather says that one should
hurry toward the synagogue but walk slowly away from it. I don’t understand
why, but I don’t ask. I’ve already noticed: Grandfather doesn’t like questions
and explanations. Whenever I ask a question, silence descends, answers are slow
in coming, and even when they do, they’re extremely brief. That no longer
bothers me now. I have also learned to remain silent and listen to the subtle
sounds that surround me. The sounds here, unlike those in the city, are
frequent but low, even if sometimes the darkness is torn by the screeching of a
We walk on for about an hour, and when we approach the house, Grandmother meets
us; she’s also dressed in white. Mother and I are wearing our usual clothes.
The Kiddush and the festive meal are quiet, like a prayer; only the four of us
are about to receive God and the Sabbath.
Mother, for some reason, is always melancholy at the Sabbath table. Sometimes
it seems to me that she once knew how to talk to God in her language, like
Grandfather and Grandmother, but because of some misunderstanding, she has
forgotten that language. On the Sabbath eve, this sorrow weighs on her.
After the Sabbath meal, we take a stroll to the stream. Grandfather and
Grandmother walk ahead, and we follow behind them. At night this branch of the
river looks wider. The darkness sinks, and white skies open above us, flowing
slowly. I stretch out my hands and feel the white flow coming straight into my
“Mother,” I say.
“What is it, my love?”
The words that I had sought to describe the sensation have slipped away from
me. Since I don’t have words, I sit there, open my eyes wide, and let the white
night flow into me.
The prayers on the Sabbath Eve are only a preparation for the prayers on the
Sabbath day, which go on for many hours. Grandfather is completely immersed in
the prayer book, and I sit next to him and see God come and sit between the
lions that are on the Holy Ark. I’m astonished that Grandfather does not seem
to get excited about something so awesome and wonderful.
“Grandfather—” I can no longer contain myself. Grandfather puts his finger to
his lips and doesn’t allow me to ask.
After some time, two men go up to the Ark, and God, who had been sitting
between the lions, is gone. His disappearance is so hasty that it’s as if He
wasn’t ever there. The two short men are not content with that: they open the
Ark. Now the Ark is wide open and prayers flow straight into it. At this point
in the proceedings, I feel very sorry that I don’t know how to pray. Two
children of around my age are already standing and praying like grown-ups. They
already know how to speak to God, and only I am mute. Sadness at this lack of
speech wells up within me, increasing from moment to moment, and I remember the
park in the city where I sometimes sit with Father. It is a park where there
are no wonders. People sit quietly on the benches. They are quiet because they
don’t know how to pray, I realize, and I snap to attention. It is at just this
moment that the Torah scroll is being taken out of the Ark and lifted high. All
eyes are turned to the Torah, and a shiver goes down my back.
The reading from the Torah on the bima, the platform in the middle of the
synagogue, is like a secret within a secret. Now it seems to me that when all
this whispering of secrets comes to an end, all these people will disappear and
I’ll be left alone, face-to-face with God, who lives in the Holy Ark. Four
people surround the Torah, speaking to it as if God were tangible in this
parchment scroll. For a moment I’m astonished that God—who’s so immense—has
squeezed Himself into this tiny platform.
After this, they roll up the Torah and sing with tremendous enthusiasm. The
four people who stood on the bima raise their voices, as if trying to
obliterate themselves. When the singing is finished, the Torah is raised and
then returned to the Holy Ark. The Ark is closed, and the parochet, the
embroidered curtain, seems to lock it in. For a moment I think that this has
been a dream, and that when I awake from it Father will carry me away from this
magic, and we’ll return to the city, back to the broad intersecting streets and
our house, which I love so much.
“Why don’t you go outside?” Grandfather’s whisper releases me.
I stand outside next to two tall trees and feel that I had been far from
myself, from my own dreams, that I visited an unknown imagination, and that
it’s good that I left and returned to myself, next to the trees that cast their
heavy shadows on the ground.
Again I look at the way the synagogue is built. The structure is so shaky that,
were it not for the ivy that envelops it and holds it together, it’s doubtful
whether it could stand on its own rickety limbs. Suddenly I’m gripped by a
great, unknown fear—a fear that in a moment the people will come out of the
building, catch hold of me, and drag me inside. This fear is so tangible that I
can feel the fingers of strangers pressing and poking me, and even the deep
“Father!” The cry escapes from my mouth, and I start to run. After I have run
part of the way, the fear leaves me and I return to the two trees at the
entrance to the synagogue. Now the prayers are quiet, and I go inside.
Grandfather is deep in prayer and does not notice that I’ve come in. I stand
next to him and look at the Holy Ark, which still seems locked up by the heavy
embroidered curtain. I try to take in one word from the many words with which
the men are talking to God, but I cannot. It’s clear now: I cannot speak.
Everyone is whispering, trying hard, and only I am without words. I stare, even
though my eyes smart. I will never be able to ask anything of God, because I
don’t know how to talk in His language. My father and mother don’t know how to
talk in His language, either. Father has already told me once, “We have nothing
but what our eyes can see.” At the time I didn’t understand this, but now it
seems to me that I have guessed what it means.
The prayers have come to an end, though I don’t realize it. The last prayer is
said amid great enthusiasm, as if it is all about to begin anew. That is the
ending, and those praying get to their feet. One of the old men comes up to me
and asks me what my name is. I am scared, and I hold on tight to Grandfather’s
coat. The old man gazes at me and doesn’t ask me anything else. Then little
honey cakes and small glasses of cognac are served, and blessings, mingling with
the smell of alcohol, waft up into the air.
After this we set out on the verdant path homeward. The sun is shining, and
herds graze on the pastures. The sight reminds me of a different quiet in
another place, but I do not know where. We cross the meadows and enter a sparse
forest. There are a few abandoned buildings in the forest. Darkness crouches in
their gaping entrances. Along the way we meet a Ruthenian peasant, an
acquaintance of Grandfather’s. They talk, and I don’t understand a word. After
that we stand on the ridge of a hill, and there seems to be great agitation—a
movement across the cornfields.
As we approach the house, I see Mother, dressed in white, standing at the
entrance. It seems to me that she is about to take off, to fly straight toward
me. This time I am right. With one swift movement, as if it weren’t Mother but a
young Ruthenian girl, she runs toward us. Only seconds later, I am in her arms.
For a moment we are together in the high grass.
In the afternoon we sit in the yard, and Grandmother brings us long rolls and
strawberries in cream. Mother is beautiful, with her hair loose over her
shoulders and lights sparkling on her long poplin dress, and I say in my
innermost being: That’s how it will be from now on. Yet, even as I am immersed
in this hidden joy, sorrow constricts my heart, so slight that I almost don’t
feel it, though, slowly and imperceptibly, it spreads inside me. I burst out
crying, and Mother, who is in a wonderful mood, gathers me in her arms. But I
am gripped, locked in this sadness and fear, and I refuse to be consoled. The
fit of crying seizes me, and I know that this is the last summer in the
village, that henceforth the light will be dimmed and darkness will seal the
And so it is that, at night, after the Sabbath, Father arrives, bringing with
him the hustle and bustle of the big city. Mother hastily packs the suitcases,
and Grandmother brings out a full crate of preserves covered in white gauze, a
crate of red apples, and two bottles of cherry liqueur that she has made
herself. The carriage is a fine one, but it doesn’t have extra room for all
this produce, and the driver can barely cram the precious gifts into the dark
space under the seats. Grandfather stands by the door, as if uprooted from the
world that he has been in. A gloomy sort of dismay radiates from his eyes. He
embraces Mother with great tenderness.
We set out in the carriage at a gallop in order to catch the last train. On the
train I am again seized by a fit of crying, and Mother tries with all her might
to calm me down, but the tears gush out of me and wet my shirt. Father’s
patience snaps, and he demands to know the reason for my tears. Though my
sorrow is piercing and the pain seems immense, I don’t have a single word to
explain it. Father’s anger increases. Eventually he can’t contain himself and
says, “If you don’t stop crying, I’ll slap you. You’re five years old, and a
child of five shouldn’t cry without a reason.”
This time Father, who almost never got angry and always remembered to bring me
presents whenever he returned from a trip, is so frightening that my tears
ceased. But Mother, who understands my pain, embraces me and draws me close to
her. I drop into her lap and fall asleep.
Excerpted from THE STORY OF A LIFE by
Aharon Appelfeld Copyright (c) 1999 by Aharon Appelfeld and Keter Publishing
House, Ltd Published by Schocken Books, a division of Random House, Inc.